Tenant Screening

How to Screen Tenants: A Step-by-Step Landlord Guide

Learn how to screen tenants the right way: rental criteria, income and reference checks, credit reports, fair housing rules and a checklist.

To screen tenants, publish written rental criteria, take complete applications from every adult, verify identity, income and rental history, run a credit and background check with the applicant's written consent, and apply the same standards to everyone. A consistent, documented process finds reliable renters and keeps you on the right side of fair housing and credit reporting laws.

Key Takeaways

  • Write your screening criteria down before you advertise and apply them the same way to every applicant.
  • Verify income with documents, and call previous landlords, not just the current one.
  • Get written consent before pulling a credit or background report, and send an adverse action notice if the report leads you to deny or change terms.
  • Never screen on race, color, religion, sex, national origin, familial status or disability, and check your state and city for more protected groups.
  • Keep records of every application and decision so you can show your process was fair.
22.7 millionRenter households spending more than 30% of income on rent and utilities in 2024, 49% of all renters (Harvard JCHS)
8.0%Average eviction filing rate across the 48 areas the Eviction Lab tracked in 2025 (Eviction Lab)
23 states + DCHad statewide source-of-income protections as of January 2025 (HUD OIG)

Step 1: Write your rental criteria before you advertise

Good screening starts before the first inquiry. Decide what a qualified applicant looks like and put it in writing: minimum income, the rental history you require, how you treat credit problems, your occupancy limits, and your pet policy. Share the criteria in your listing or with every applicant so people can decide whether to apply.

Written criteria do two jobs. They save you time by filtering out applicants who don't qualify, and they protect you if a rejected applicant claims you treated them unfairly. Common criteria include:

  • Income: many landlords look for gross monthly income of about three times the rent. Decide how you'll count vouchers, benefits, self-employment and co-signers.
  • Rental history: for example, no evictions in the last several years and positive references from past landlords.
  • Credit: what you'll look at (unpaid rent or utility collections usually matter more than old medical debt).
  • Occupancy: a reasonable limit, often based on local codes, rather than a rule about children.

Step 2: Take a complete application from every adult

Ask every adult who will live in the unit to fill out an application. A useful application collects:

  • Full legal name, date of birth and contact information
  • Current and previous addresses for at least the last few years, with landlord names and phone numbers
  • Employer, position, income and how long they've worked there
  • Written permission to run a credit and background check
  • Number of occupants and any pets

Review applications in the order you receive them and decide on each one before moving to the next. First-come, first-qualified is simple to explain and easy to defend.

Check your state's rules on application fees before you charge one. New York, for example, limits the fee for a credit and background check to $20 or the actual cost, whichever is less, and requires you to give the applicant a copy of the report and the receipt, according to the New York Attorney General. Other states cap fees, require refunds of unused fees, or let applicants supply a recent screening report of their own.

Step 3: Verify identity and income

Match a government-issued photo ID to the name on the application. Then verify income with documents rather than taking the number on the form at face value.

Applicant situationDocuments to ask for
EmployedTwo to three recent pay stubs, or an offer letter for a new job
Self-employedRecent tax returns and several months of bank statements
Housing voucher or benefitsThe award letter or voucher paperwork showing the monthly amount
Retired or living on savingsRetirement or Social Security statements, or proof of assets

A quick call to the employer's main number (not the number written on the application) confirms the job is real. Many places protect applicants based on their source of income. As of January 2025, 23 states and DC had statewide laws, and more than 150 cities and counties had local ones, according to a HUD Office of Inspector General report. If you're covered, you must count lawful income like housing vouchers the same way you count wages.

Step 4: Check rental history and references

Past behavior as a tenant is the best predictor of future behavior, and payment trouble is common right now: in Urban Institute survey results reported by CRE Daily, the share of working-age, middle-income renters who couldn't pay the full rent at some point in the year rose from 14.3% in 2024 to 21.6% in 2025. Call at least the last two landlords. The current landlord may give a glowing review just to see a difficult tenant leave, so the previous one is often more candid. Ask questions with factual answers:

  1. What dates did the applicant rent from you, and what was the rent?
  2. Did they pay on time? Were there any late or missed payments?
  3. Did you keep any of the security deposit, and why?
  4. Did they give proper notice before moving out?
  5. Would you rent to them again?

Confirm the reference is really the owner or manager by checking county property records or the management company's public phone number.

Step 5: Run credit and background checks the right way

Use a tenant screening company and get the applicant's written consent first. Tenant screening reports are consumer reports under the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act, and that law comes with duties for landlords.

The biggest one: if anything in the report leads you to deny the application, require a co-signer, ask for a bigger deposit or charge higher rent, you must give the applicant an adverse action notice. The notice names the company that supplied the report, says that company didn't make the decision, and explains the applicant's right to a free copy of the report and to dispute errors. The FTC's guide Using Consumer Reports: What Landlords Need to Know lays out the details.

Look at criminal history carefully. A blanket rule against anyone with any record can screen out applicants unfairly and can create fair housing risk. Arrests that didn't lead to a conviction say little about someone as a tenant. Focus on recent convictions that relate to the safety of people and property, and consider how long ago the offense happened. Several states and cities also limit what landlords can ask or consider, so check local rules before you set a policy.

Step 6: Make a fair, documented decision

Compare each application against your written criteria, not against a gut feeling or the other applicants' personalities. Under the federal Fair Housing Act, you can't refuse to rent, set different terms, or say a unit is unavailable because of race, color, religion, sex, national origin, familial status or disability. Many states and cities add more groups, such as source of income, age, marital status, sexual orientation or gender identity.

Applicants with disabilities can ask for reasonable accommodations, such as an assistance animal in a building with a no-pet rule. Treat those requests as part of the process, not a reason to reject.

Keep each application, the reports, your notes and your decision for a few years. If you approve, move quickly to a signed lease and deposit so a good applicant doesn't take another offer. If you deny, send the notices your state and the FCRA require. Rent Duck's landlord resources page has more checklists for the lease-signing and move-in steps.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does tenant screening take?

Most landlords finish screening in one to three business days. Online credit and background reports usually come back within minutes once the applicant gives consent. The slowest parts are reaching past landlords and employers, so ask applicants for current phone numbers and let references know to expect your call.

What credit score should a tenant have?

There is no legal minimum, and many landlords care less about the score than about what's behind it. Unpaid rent, eviction-related debt and utility collections are stronger warning signs than a thin credit file or old medical bills. Whatever standard you choose, write it down and use it for every applicant.

Can I charge an application fee?

In most states, yes, but many states and cities limit how much you can charge or require you to show what the screening cost. New York caps the credit and background check fee at $20. Check your state law and local rules before you set a fee, and never charge for a unit that's no longer available.

Can I reject a tenant for having a housing voucher?

It depends on where the rental is. Federal law doesn't list source of income as a protected class, but a growing number of states, counties and cities do. In those places, refusing an applicant because they pay with a voucher, or applying a stricter income test to them, can be illegal. Check your state and local fair housing rules.

Do I have to tell an applicant why I denied them?

If the decision was based in any way on a credit or background report, the Fair Credit Reporting Act requires an adverse action notice that names the screening company and explains the applicant's rights. Some states require you to state the specific reason for a denial. Giving a short, factual reason tied to your written criteria is a good habit everywhere.

Screen consistently and you'll rent with confidence

A clear, written process makes tenant screening faster and fairer: publish your criteria, verify what applicants tell you, follow credit reporting rules, and treat every applicant the same way. When you're ready to find applicants, you can list your rental on Rent Duck for free, or hire a property manager to handle screening for you.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Check your state and local rules or talk to a local attorney before acting.

Comments

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Find your next rental on Rent Duck

Homes, apartments, offices, storage and more, listed by owners and property managers near you.