Search Anything.
List Everything.
Unlimited free listings
Residential Student Housing Commercial Vacation Rentals Storage / Warehouse

Explore 81 rentals on the map

Browse every listing and see where it is

Residential for Rent in Fleming Island, FL (81)

4 bed 2 bath rental in Green Cove Springs, FL: Spacious 4-Bedroom Home in Desirable Cross Creek Community
Spacious 4-Bedroom Home in Desirable Cross Creek Community
3174 Rustic Deer Way, Green Cove Springs, FL
Bedrooms 4 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 1,856 sqft
74 Proximity Score
$2,200/mo
3 bed 2 bath rental in Orange Park, FL: 3 Bed 2 Bath Single family for Rent - Orange Park, FL - $1,695/mo
3 Bed 2 Bath Single family for Rent - Orange Park, FL - $1,695/mo
584 Madeira Drive, Orange Park, FL
Bedrooms 3 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 1,272 sqft
97 Proximity Score
$1,695/mo
3 bed 2.5 bath rental in Orange Park, FL: 433 Running Woods St, Orange Park, FL 32065
433 Running Woods St, Orange Park, FL 32065
433 Running Woods Street, Orange Park, FL
Bedrooms 3 bdBathrooms 2.5 baSquare feet 1,308 sqft
$1,795/mo
3 bed 2 bath rental in Orange Park, FL: $1,595 - 3 Bedroom 2 Bathroom House In Orange Park With Great Amenities
$1,595 - 3 Bedroom 2 Bathroom House In Orange Park With Great Amenities
514 W Clermont Dr, Orange Park, FL
Bedrooms 3 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 1,300 sqft
96 Proximity Score
$1,595/mo
3 bed 2 bath rental in Middleburg, FL: 3 Bed 2 Bath Condo for Rent - Middleburg, FL - $1,595/mo
3 Bed 2 Bath Condo for Rent - Middleburg, FL - $1,595/mo
4211 Sandhill Crane Ter, Middleburg, FL
Bedrooms 3 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 1,535 sqft
$1,595/mo
2 bed 3 bath rental in Fleming Island, FL: Charming Villa with Community Amenities in Lake Ridge Villas North
Charming Villa with Community Amenities in Lake Ridge Villas North
1500 Calming Water Drive, Fleming Island, FL
Bedrooms 2 bdBathrooms 3 baSquare feet 1,296 sqft
89 Proximity Score
$1,750/mo
2 bed 2.5 bath rental in Saint Johns, FL: 1036 N Black Cherry Dr, Saint Johns, FL 32259
1036 N Black Cherry Dr, Saint Johns, FL 32259
1036 N Black Cherry Dr, Saint Johns, FL
Bedrooms 2 bdBathrooms 2.5 baSquare feet 1,268 sqft
94 Proximity Score
$1,795/mo
5 bed 4 bath rental in St Johns, FL: St. Johns Forest - Pool Home - 5 Bed - 3.5 Bath
St. Johns Forest - Pool Home - 5 Bed - 3.5 Bath
1205 Matengo Circle, St Johns, FL
Bedrooms 5 bdBathrooms 4 baSquare feet 3,201 sqft
95 Proximity Score
$3,870/mo
2 bed 2 bath rental in Orange Park, FL: 2 Bed 2 Bath Single family for Rent - Orange Park, FL - $1,075/mo
2 Bed 2 Bath Single family for Rent - Orange Park, FL - $1,075/mo
456 Crabapple Court - A, Orange Park, FL
Bedrooms 2 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 920 sqft
97 Proximity Score
$1,075/mo
4 bed 2 bath rental in Middleburg, FL: Spacious 4-Bedroom Home in Two Creeks – Community Amenities, Fenced Backyard & Pet Friendly!
Spacious 4-Bedroom Home in Two Creeks – Community Amenities, Fenced Backyard & Pet Friendly!
1016 Grackle Ct, Middleburg, FL
Bedrooms 4 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 1,860 sqft
$2,200/mo
2 bed 2 bath rental in Orange Park, FL: 2 Bed 2 Bath Single family for Rent - Orange Park, FL - $1,300/mo
2 Bed 2 Bath Single family for Rent - Orange Park, FL - $1,300/mo
1290 Jefferson Avenue, Orange Park, FL
Bedrooms 2 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 922 sqft
$1,300/mo
4 bed 3 bath rental in St Johns, FL: 192 Rambling Brook Trail
192 Rambling Brook Trail
192 Rambling Brook Trail, St Johns, FL
Bedrooms 4 bdBathrooms 3 baSquare feet 2,387 sqft
93 Proximity Score
$2,650/mo
2 bed 2 bath rental in Orange Park, FL: Spacious 2-Bedroom Apartment with Brand-New LVP Flooring in Cedar Bend!
Spacious 2-Bedroom Apartment with Brand-New LVP Flooring in Cedar Bend!
480 Bentwood Lane, Orange Park, FL
Bedrooms 2 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 920 sqft
97 Proximity Score
$1,050/mo
3 bed 2 bath rental in Middleburg, FL: 3 Bed 2 Bath Condo for Rent - Middleburg, FL - $1,395/mo
3 Bed 2 Bath Condo for Rent - Middleburg, FL - $1,395/mo
1867 Sheraton Lks Cir, Middleburg, FL
Bedrooms 3 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 1,296 sqft
$1,395/mo
4 bed 3 bath rental in Middleburg, FL: 4 Bed 3 Bath Single family for Rent - Middleburg, FL - $2,100/mo
4 Bed 3 Bath Single family for Rent - Middleburg, FL - $2,100/mo
3770 Bedford Dr, Middleburg, FL
Bedrooms 4 bdBathrooms 3 baSquare feet 2,496 sqft
$2,100/mo
3 bed 3 bath rental in Middleburg, FL: New Build | Attached Garage | Pet Friendly
New Build | Attached Garage | Pet Friendly
3879 Athenian Way, Middleburg, FL
Bedrooms 3 bdBathrooms 3 baSquare feet 1,433 sqft
$1,945/mo
3 bed 2 bath rental in Orange Park, FL: 3 Bed 2 Bath Condo for Rent - Orange Park, FL - $1,500/mo
3 Bed 2 Bath Condo for Rent - Orange Park, FL - $1,500/mo
230 Foxridge Rd, Orange Park, FL
Bedrooms 3 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 1,676 sqft
$1,500/mo
3 bed 2 bath rental in Orange Park, FL: 3Br/2Ba in The Meadows
3Br/2Ba in The Meadows
2632 Grafton Dr, Orange Park, FL
Bedrooms 3 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 1,431 sqft
$1,750/mo
4 bed 3 bath rental in Fleming Island, FL: 4 Bed 3 Bath Single family for Rent - Fleming Island, FL
4 Bed 3 Bath Single family for Rent - Fleming Island, FL
198 Eventide Drive, Fleming Island, FL
Bedrooms 4 bdBathrooms 3 baSquare feet 3,600 sqft
92 Proximity Score
$3,600/mo
3 bed 2 bath rental in Orange Park, FL: $1,800 - 3 Bedroom 2 Bathroom House In Orange Park With Great Amenities
$1,800 - 3 Bedroom 2 Bathroom House In Orange Park With Great Amenities
584 Madeira Drive, Orange Park, FL
Bedrooms 3 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 1,272 sqft
97 Proximity Score
$1,800/mo
2 bed 3 bath rental in Middleburg, FL: 2 Bed 3 Bath Single family for Rent - Middleburg, FL - $1,675/mo
2 Bed 3 Bath Single family for Rent - Middleburg, FL - $1,675/mo
4129 Quiet Creek Loop, Middleburg, FL
Bedrooms 2 bdBathrooms 3 baSquare feet 1,157 sqft
$1,675/mo
3 bed 2 bath rental in Middleburg, FL: 3 Bed 2 Bath Condo for Rent - Middleburg, FL - $1,595/mo
3 Bed 2 Bath Condo for Rent - Middleburg, FL - $1,595/mo
4211 Sandhill Crane Ter, Middleburg, FL
Bedrooms 3 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 1,535 sqft
$1,595/mo
3 bed 3 bath rental in Middleburg, FL: New Build | Attached Garage | Pet Friendly
New Build | Attached Garage | Pet Friendly
3875 Athenian Way, Middleburg, FL
Bedrooms 3 bdBathrooms 3 baSquare feet 1,433 sqft
$1,945/mo
2 bed 3 bath rental in Middleburg, FL: Charming Middleburg Townhome with Garage In Kindlewood!
Charming Middleburg Townhome with Garage In Kindlewood!
827 Rivertree Place, Middleburg, FL
Bedrooms 2 bdBathrooms 3 baSquare feet 1,160 sqft
$1,600/mo

About Residential for Rent in Fleming Island, FL

Rent Duck has 14 residential listings in Fleming Island, FL. Monthly rent runs from $1,288 to $4,200, with a median of $2,250. Nearby, there are also listings in Orange Park, St Johns and Saint Johns. Each listing shows photos, the price and details, and you can contact the owner or property manager from it for free.

More Rentals in Fleming Island, FL

Rent Duck
Making rental searches simple, transparent, and accessible for everyone.

For Renters

For Landlords

Company

© 2026 Rent Duck. All rights reserved. IP Geolocation by DB-IP