Search Anything.
List Everything.
Unlimited free listings
Residential Student Housing Commercial Vacation Rentals Storage / Warehouse
All Condo Short Term Multi-family Single family

Explore 63 rentals on the map

Browse every listing and see where it is

Single family for Rent in Fleming Island, FL (63)

2 bed 2 bath rental in Middleburg, FL: 2-bed / 2-bath with a large yard and lots of trees
2-bed / 2-bath with a large yard and lots of trees
2256 S Mimosa Ave, Middleburg, FL
Bedrooms 2 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 980 sqft
$1,000/mo
4 bed 2 bath rental in Orange Park, FL: 4 Bed 2 Bath Single family for Rent - Orange Park, FL - $1,974/mo
4 Bed 2 Bath Single family for Rent - Orange Park, FL - $1,974/mo
383 Turtle Dove Dr, Orange Park, FL
Bedrooms 4 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 1,871 sqft
$1,974/mo
3 bed 2 bath rental in Middleburg, FL: Pet Friendly | Attached Garage | Covered Front Porch
Pet Friendly | Attached Garage | Covered Front Porch
1715 Dalby Ct, Middleburg, FL
Bedrooms 3 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 1,392 sqft
$1,805/mo
2 bed 2 bath rental in Orange Park, FL: 2 Bed 2 Bath Single family for Rent - Orange Park, FL - $1,075/mo
2 Bed 2 Bath Single family for Rent - Orange Park, FL - $1,075/mo
470 Crabapple Court - A, Orange Park, FL
Bedrooms 2 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 920 sqft
97 Proximity Score
$1,075/mo
2 bed 2 bath rental in Orange Park, FL: 2 Bed 2 Bath Single family for Rent - Orange Park, FL - $1,300/mo
2 Bed 2 Bath Single family for Rent - Orange Park, FL - $1,300/mo
1278 Montecello Drive - B, Orange Park, FL
Bedrooms 2 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 922 sqft
$1,300/mo
3 bed 2 bath rental in Fleming Island, FL: 3 Bed 2 Bath Single family for Rent - Fleming Island, FL
3 Bed 2 Bath Single family for Rent - Fleming Island, FL
3165 Creighton Forest Drive, Fleming Island, FL
Bedrooms 3 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 1,949 sqft
96 Proximity Score
$3,200/mo
4 bed 2.5 bath rental in Orange Park, FL: $3,100 - 4 Bedroom 2.5 Bathroom House In Orange Park With Great Amenities
$3,100 - 4 Bedroom 2.5 Bathroom House In Orange Park With Great Amenities
2865 Firethorn Avenue, Orange Park, FL
Bedrooms 4 bdBathrooms 2.5 baSquare feet 2,450 sqft
$3,000/mo
4 bed 2 bath rental in Orange Park, FL: Oakleaf 4 bedroom, fenced on a pond!
Oakleaf 4 bedroom, fenced on a pond!
4559 Plantation Oaks Blvd, Orange Park, FL
Bedrooms 4 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 2,191 sqft
$2,600/mo
3 bed 3 bath rental in Fleming Island, FL: Beautiful Eagle Harbor Townhome – Space, Style & Resort-Style Living!
Beautiful Eagle Harbor Townhome – Space, Style & Resort-Style Living!
2317 Old Pine Trail, Fleming Island, FL
Bedrooms 3 bdBathrooms 3 baSquare feet 1,600 sqft
90 Proximity Score
$2,100/mo
1 bed 1 bath rental in Fleming Island, FL: 1 Bed 1 Bath Single family for Rent - Fleming Island, FL
1 Bed 1 Bath Single family for Rent - Fleming Island, FL
2200 Marsh Hawk Ln, Fleming Island, FL
Bedrooms 1 bdBathrooms 1 baSquare feet 883 sqft
90 Proximity Score
$1,288/mo
3 bed 2 bath rental in Orange Park, FL: 3 Bed 2 Bath Single family for Rent - Orange Park, FL - $2,300/mo
3 Bed 2 Bath Single family for Rent - Orange Park, FL - $2,300/mo
3400 Red Oak Circle, Orange Park, FL
Bedrooms 3 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 1,675 sqft
96 Proximity Score
$2,300/mo
3 bed 2 bath rental in Fleming Island, FL: 3 Bed 2 Bath Single family for Rent - Fleming Island, FL
3 Bed 2 Bath Single family for Rent - Fleming Island, FL
1644 Hampton Pl, Fleming Island, FL
Bedrooms 3 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 1,744 sqft
93 Proximity Score
$2,400/mo
3 bed 2 bath rental in Orange Park, FL: 3 Bed/2 Bath Eagle Landing Community Home Available Now!
3 Bed/2 Bath Eagle Landing Community Home Available Now!
1512 Autumn Pines Dr., Orange Park, FL
Bedrooms 3 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 1,911 sqft
$2,500/mo
3 bed 2 bath rental in Orange Park, FL: 3 bedroom / 2 bath Gem with Pond Views in Spencer's Plantation!
3 bedroom / 2 bath Gem with Pond Views in Spencer's Plantation!
3174 White Heron Trail, Orange Park, FL
Bedrooms 3 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 1,649 sqft
$1,900/mo
5 bed 3 bath rental in Orange Park, FL: $2,950 - 5 Bedroom 3 Bathroom House In Orange Park With Great Amenities
$2,950 - 5 Bedroom 3 Bathroom House In Orange Park With Great Amenities
935 Anna Avenue, Orange Park, FL
Bedrooms 5 bdBathrooms 3 baSquare feet 3,476 sqft
98 Proximity Score
$2,950/mo
2 bed 2 bath rental in Fleming Island, FL: 2 Bed 2 Bath Single family for Rent - Fleming Island, FL
2 Bed 2 Bath Single family for Rent - Fleming Island, FL
1717 County Road 220, Unit 107, Fleming Island, FL
Bedrooms 2 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 1,104 sqft
92 Proximity Score
$1,450/mo
2 bed 2 bath rental in Orange Park, FL: 2 Bed 2 Bath Single family for Rent - Orange Park, FL - $1,195/mo
2 Bed 2 Bath Single family for Rent - Orange Park, FL - $1,195/mo
702 Meadowbrook Drive - 8, Orange Park, FL
Bedrooms 2 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 920 sqft
97 Proximity Score
$1,195/mo
4 bed 3 bath rental in Orange Park, FL: Spacious 4-Bedroom Home in Sugar Leaf Farms
Spacious 4-Bedroom Home in Sugar Leaf Farms
3435 Auvenshine Way, Orange Park, FL
Bedrooms 4 bdBathrooms 3 baSquare feet 2,389 sqft
$2,700/mo
5 bed 3 bath rental in Orange Park, FL: BEAUTIFUL OAKLEAF PLANTATION
BEAUTIFUL OAKLEAF PLANTATION
3041 SOUTHHALL COURT, Orange Park, FL
Bedrooms 5 bdBathrooms 3 baSquare feet 2,427 sqft
$2,395/mo
3 bed 2 bath rental in Fleming Island, FL: Fantastic 3 bedroom Fleming Island home!
Fantastic 3 bedroom Fleming Island home!
6106 Pine Avenue, Fleming Island, FL
Bedrooms 3 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 1,773 sqft
$1,845/mo
5 bed 5 bath rental in Fleming Island, FL: Spacious 5BR/5BA Home with Screened Pool & Pond View in Eagle Harbor at Black Creek!
Spacious 5BR/5BA Home with Screened Pool & Pond View in Eagle Harbor at Black Creek!
2723 Shade Tree Dr, Fleming Island, FL
Bedrooms 5 bdBathrooms 5 baSquare feet 4,538 sqft
86 Proximity Score
$4,200/mo
4 bed 2 bath rental in Middleburg, FL: Handicap friendly pool home
Handicap friendly pool home
1819 The Glades Rd, Middleburg, FL
Bedrooms 4 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 2,259 sqft
$2,700/mo
4 bed 2 bath rental in Green Cove Springs, FL: Spacious 4-Bedroom Home in Desirable Cross Creek Community
Spacious 4-Bedroom Home in Desirable Cross Creek Community
3174 Rustic Deer Way, Green Cove Springs, FL
Bedrooms 4 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 1,856 sqft
74 Proximity Score
$2,200/mo
3 bed 2 bath rental in Orange Park, FL: 3 Bed 2 Bath Single family for Rent - Orange Park, FL - $1,695/mo
3 Bed 2 Bath Single family for Rent - Orange Park, FL - $1,695/mo
584 Madeira Drive, Orange Park, FL
Bedrooms 3 bdBathrooms 2 baSquare feet 1,272 sqft
97 Proximity Score
$1,695/mo

About Single family for Rent in Fleming Island, FL

Rent Duck has 11 single family listings in Fleming Island, FL. Monthly rent runs from $1,288 to $4,200, with a median of $2,400. Nearby, there are also listings in Orange Park, St Johns and Saint Johns. Each listing shows photos, the price and details, and you can contact the owner or property manager from it for free.

More Rentals in Fleming Island, FL

Rent Duck
Making rental searches simple, transparent, and accessible for everyone.

For Renters

For Landlords

Company

© 2026 Rent Duck. All rights reserved. IP Geolocation by DB-IP